“Birthright”
Thursday, December 13th, 2007
I’m sad there is only one new episode of Criminal Minds. Shows like “Birthright” remind me how exciting and interesting the show is. The story involved missing and murdered young women in Virginia. As the team investigates, they find a victim of a similar crime that had happened 27 years ago. There was a series of killings in 1980, and this woman is the only survivor. She says she can’t help when the profilers come to talk to her, but she doesn’t appear frightened that the killer could be back. This leads them to believe the killer is dead, and they are led to his sons. They find out that the victim had become pregnant by her captor and had the child. They suspect him and go to talk to him. He knew about his father, but he cared so much about his mother that he never told her he knew - he played along with her lie.
The killer also had a son by his wife, who becomes the prime suspect. He doesn’t show up for work, and the BAU goes to his house.
There, they find a pregnant wife and a barn. As they search the barn, they find signs that he’d been torturing women there, but not holding them there. Now they need to figure out where the women are being held. They bring the only survivor of the 1980 crimes to the scene, hoping she can help in some way. She sees her captor’s wife and starts yelling at her…why didnt’s she stop him? Why didn’t she help her? She must have known what’s going on. The wife becomes so upset that she blurts out that she killed him. This kind of takes everyone aback. She said she came home - while pregnant, by the way - and saw all the blood. She figured out what was going on and killed her husband so he wouldn’t hurt anyone else. She didn’t want her son to know that his father was a murderer. But he does find out and continues his father’s legacy.
The surviving victim remembers walking to the barn, a long walk, uphill, with boulders along the way. The wife then remembers a piece of property that fits the description, and the team is led to the women. But not the killer.
Meanwhile, the killer’s pregnant wife goes to a spot where she knows he goes to be alone. She confronts him, and as the BAU is rushing to find him, they hear a shot. When they come to the scene, the killer is laying on the ground. His wife says that he came after her and she had to shoot him. She looks at the first killer’s wife, and it’s understood that that wasn’t exactly the case. She killed him for the same reasons his mother had killed his father.
It was perfectly symmetrical, and you kind of wonder what this unborn baby is going to turn out like.
Anyway, it was an interesting episode, and the story was entertaining. JJ gets a little more focus in “Birthright.” She is extremely bothered by this case. Hotch points out to her that the victims of crimes they investigate tend to be around her age. She identifies with them, and is wondering if she can stop caring so it’d be easier.
We also discover the mystery of the bracelet Rossi carries. He’s talking to the sheriff who investigated the 1980 crimes. This guy was haunted by the case, he knew every detail, but he couldn’t solve it back then. Rossi tells him that he carries this bracelet because he had a case where three children watched their parents get beaten to death on Christmas Eve. He promised them that he’d find their killer, but he need succeeded. This has bothered him for 21 years. And he notes, that every Christmas Eve, he calls to tell the children that he hasn’t forgotten and will find the killer. Last year, none of them bothered to return his call.
I liked how they used the former sheriff as a way for Rossi to tell his story. At the end, the former sheriff tells Rossi not to let it get to 22 - meaning not to let another year go by with his haunting case hanging over his head.
Hotch is also served with divorce papers at the end of the episode.


So AJ didn’t come from nowhere. You can also see an interview she gives about her character, JJ at
AJ Cook talks about how the show will introduce Joe Mantegna’s new character, while at the same time explaining Agent Gideon’s (Mandy Patinkin) departure.
Thomas Gibson was also disappointed: “We look at this as a great opportunity to shake things up. This is certainly a disappointment to everyone, but I don’t think it’s a catastrophe.”
In 1973, only 24 out of 8,767 FBI agents were women. In 2007 there are 30,646 agents, 13,692 of whom are women. The percentage is smaller in the BAU, but on Criminal Minds, women are well represented by Emily Prentiss (Paget Brewster), JJ (AJ Cook), and Penelope Garcia (Kirsten Vangsness). These agents each bring unique skills to the team, without which they wouldn’t be as successful.